My favorite eye liner pencils are the ones put out my Eye or Horus or Rimmel.
I dont like black eye liner as for me it is way to harsh so I tend to go for a brown or a colour

If you’re after a recommendation for eye liner pencils, I love the pencil that comes in my Lancome Hypnose Drama set. The formula works really well for my skin, doesn’t smudge or show fall out, and doesn’t irritate my eyes. For a more cost effective option, I’ve heard great things about the Maybelline Kajal pencil (currently on sale at Coles)