I get the same. My eyes tend to water when I laugh or smile and then my eyes will sting from the sunscreen or mascara, I use anthelios also but I mostly try and use an spf foundation because that doesn’t seem to get in my eyes as much.

Its not even a case of sensitive skin, just my eyes get hot and watery after a few hours of wear. I suspect this is a case of ‘no longer in my twenties’, it was never an issue before. I’ve had to switch mascara for the same reason.

Do you have sensitive skin around the eyes or allergies? I’d opt for something fragrance free and gentle.

I use the Neutrogena Dry Touch in the blue tube and dont have any issues.
I have also used to one for babies that comes in the pink tube. That might be worth a try as its obviously gentle.